The Pirates needed only to win 19 more games to achieve a winning record. Instead, they reverted to the pathetic losers of yesteryear and proceeded to lose 36 games. On September 28th the Pirates were mathematically eliminated from climbing the Great Wall of Winners by losing 1-0 to none other than the Reds. They finished the season a disappointingly close 79-83, their best record since 1992. If only that record could reflect how well the team played for three-quarters of the season.
The team treated its fans to a roller coaster ride of a season. The months of April and May started out slow. The Bucs were up and down throughout most of the spring but finished out the month of May with a 25-25 record. Fans remained skeptical. June and July sent Pirates faithful into hysteria. Players began harnessing the power of Zoltan. Drawing inspiration from the cult film Dude, Where’s My Car? the team began making a “Z” with their hands when they got a hit to imitate an iconic scene from the movie Gradually fans embraced the Zoltan too, even designing shirts and posters that displayed the “Z.” The whirlwind of hype and hope that surrounded the team gave the baseball world a feeling that the woeful Pittsburgh team would finally do something special.
Pirates catcher Rod Barajas popularizing the Zoltan |
And then August decided to rear its ugly head. Though the pitching rotation had slowed substantially (James McDonald in particular), the Pirates had managed to string together enough wins to compete for one of the NL Wild Card spots. Yet suddenly, as mysteriously as their meteoric rise through the baseball ranks had begun, it deteriorated. Strikeouts, strikeouts everywhere. ERAs that ballooned out of control. Relievers that offered as much relief as Tylenol would for a root canal. Did I mention that they were losing?
Not only was the team doing poorly, Andrew McCutchen, their hero, their savior, slipped into a terrible slump. On August 17 his batting average hit .360. It would not eclipse that mark the rest of the season. Though he still maintained his position of one of the MLB’s best players, his average steadily declined as Cutch struck out more and more. Pirates fans whose hopes of a winning season were dwindling now saw their aspirations of an MVP candidate going down the drain as well. McCutchen would finish out the season with a .327 average, nine points behind Buster Posey of the San Francisco Giants.
Even Pirates center fielder Andrew McCutchen was unable to escape his team's late season slump. |
The Pirates’ collapse begs inquiry. How could one of the hottest teams in professional baseball, on the verge of salvaging 19 years of losing, possibly take such a titanic plunge into the depths of failure? Many of the most renowned baseball analysts will cut to the root of the matter by supplying facts and statistics. “McCutchen’s swing is off,” one might suggest. “The right guys aren't in the rotation right now,” says another. “Alvarez should have batted fifth, not sixth.”
The critics can make those types of arguments all day, and maybe some of them were right, but put simply, the Pirates remembered that they were the Pirates. The team wasn't used to winning seven to ten games in a row like the Yankees or the Rangers. What they were used to was losing. Late in the season when they succumbed to five or six game losing streaks more frequently, they fell into the trap of not believing in themselves. Whether or not the solid coaching or the faith of the players faltered, the results on the field did not mirror their successful playing style earlier in the season, and analysts and fans everywhere took notice.
Personally, I turn to social media outlets like Twitter and Facebook for information about popular baseball opinions amongst fans. When the Pirates were winning, fans came out of the woodwork, praising their team for accomplishing what most thought impossible. Some of the more optimistic ones even championed them as “World Series bound.” Naivety at its finest. Yet when August came around, these fans were nowhere to be heard, didn’t even show up at their hearings to eat crow. First things first, Pirates fans: we don’t have to right to talk smack until our team actually finishes over .500 by for the first time in almost as many years as I’ve been on this earth.
If any bright spot can be found in the nightmarish conclusion to the Pirates' season, it comes in the form of the talent that is currently on the team. As of now, the Bucs haven’t lost any major players to other teams. McCutchen will of course still headline the ball club as the juggernaut all-star. Other notable returning offensive players include Neil Walker, Garrett Jones, Pedro Alvarez, and Michael McKenry. The pitching staff will also return ace A.J. Burnett, closer Joel Hanrahan, and other contributors James McDonald and Wandy Rodriguez. With the core of the team returning, they have the advantage of understanding what winning feels like and can take the necessary steps to improve in order to sustain that winning deep into September.
From left to right: Andrew McCutchen, Neil Walker, and Garrett Jones |
For the more symbolic optimists out there, they can turn to the number of consecutive losing seasons suffered by the Pirates: 20. If they lost one more, it would bring their grand total to (you guessed it, mathletes) 21, which is coincidentally the number worn by arguably the greatest Pirate ever, Roberto Clemente. A member of the 3000 Hit Club, Clemente was killed flying a relief mission to Nicaragua in 1972, but managed to achieve exactly 3000 hits before doing so. I don’t usually look to “signs” to indicate how a situation will play out, but if there was any season where the possibility of breaking the curse would seem the strongest, 2013 is a strong candidate. To associate the number 21 with the longest losing streak in professional sports would quite simply sully the legacy Clemente cemented in Pittsburgh.
So next year around this time, take a look at the National League standings on ESPN.com. Note the small “z” next to the Pirates that indicates “Clinched Playoff Berth.” Observe how many points over .500 the team is. October baseball will return, Pirates fans. Sooner, rather than later.